All news
Politics
Business
Technology
Incidents
Sports
Weather
Science
Entertainment
World
Real Estate
AI News
Gilmar and Mendonça clash during STF session, and senior justice claims colleague pursued 'political-electoral' approach in Master casePhoto by Endzeiter on Pexels
Politics
Investments
Elections

Gilmar and Mendonça clash during STF session, and senior justice claims colleague pursued 'political-electoral' approach in Master case

oglobo15 September 2026 at 16:46

Justices Gilmar Mendes and André Mendonça had an exchange during Tuesday's session of the Supreme Federal Court (STF). Senior Justice Gilmar accused his colleague of adopting a political-electoral tone in handling the Master case, related to PET 16.662. Gilmar specifically criticized the choice of September 7 as the trial date, also mentioning the presence of dolls with Mendonça's face at rallies by supporters of PL candidate for President, Flávio Bolsonaro.

In response, Mendonça said Gilmar was being frivolous and asked him not to point his finger at him. "That's not done. Decent people don't do that," Mendonça said. Mendonça then demanded respect, saying: "Don't point your finger at me, Justice Gilmar. You're not talking to just anyone. Respect this court." Gilmar responded: "Those who don't respect themselves don't deserve respect."

Why this matters

The confrontation between two of the eleven STF justices reveals political tensions within the country's highest court, especially at a moment when the Master case involves figures close to the family circle of former President Bolsonaro. The episode may affect the court's credibility and perception of impartiality in cases of high political relevance on the eve of an electoral process.

About this summary

This is our short summary of a report published by oglobo on 15 September 2026 at 16:46; the full text stays with the publisher. In our feed it sits under Politics. We currently carry 30761 items in that section.

All items in this section →
Source

Related articles

Imposto sobre lucros extra das petrolíferas "não vai dar em nada": "É só fazer de conta que se está a distribuir o esforço desta subida dos combustíveis"Photo by paulbr75 on Pexels
Politics

Tax on oil companies' extra profits "will lead to nothing": "It's just pretending that the effort of this fuel price increase is being distributed"

Pedro Santos Guerreiro, executive director of CNN Portugal, criticized the Government's measure to tax oil companies' extra profits, arguing that it will have no practical effects and that the executive is just "pretending to do something" to combat the rising cost of living, when in reality it has more tools at its disposal to help citizens.

CNN Portugal15/09/26, 20:11
"O Governo ganhou 700 milhões de euros em IVA e devolveu 700 milhões de euros em ISP. Aquilo que deu com uma mão tirou com a outra"Photo by Ralphs_Fotos on Pexels
Politics

"The Government collected 700 million euros in VAT and returned 700 million euros in ISP. What it gave with one hand it took away with the other"

António Mendonça Mendes, from the PS (Socialist Party), criticized the fiscal policy of the Government of Luís Montenegro, stating that the executive collected 700 million euros in VAT but simultaneously returned the same amount in ISP, resulting in a neutral effect for citizens. The socialist official argues that the measures to support the cost of living are illusory, given that what the government "gave with one hand it took away with the other."

CNN Portugal15/09/26, 20:10
"O que o Governo está agora a dar não se materializa em nada na melhoria da vida das pessoas"Photo by planet_fox on Pexels
Politics

"What the Government is now giving does not materialise in anything that improves people's lives"

The Chega MP, Ricardo Reis, criticised the Portuguese government's measures, stating that the implemented policies do not translate into a real improvement in citizens' lives, and that if people are asked whether they feel the discount at the fuel pump, the answer will be negative.

CNN Portugal15/09/26, 20:10
"Não são só os combustíveis. O preço da habitação e das rendas está a subir e o Governo não está a tomar medidas absolutamente nenhumas"Photo by JHertle on Pexels
Politics

"It's not just fuels. Housing and rental prices are rising and the Government is not taking absolutely any measures"

The MP from Livre Paulo Muacho criticized the inaction of the Government of Luís Montenegro regarding the increase in the cost of living in Portugal, highlighting that it is not only fuels that are more expensive, but also housing prices and rents continue to rise without the executive taking concrete measures to stop this trend.

CNN Portugal15/09/26, 20:06